About Theology in the Vineyard

Theology in the Vineyard is a blog edited by Ted Schmidt a pure product of Vatican ll, the energizing reform movement in the Catholic Church.Growing up on a Jewish street in downtown Toronto, he was exposed to the searing experience of the Shoah at an early age. He was the first educator in Canada to institutionalize this in his teaching and the universal lessons of “silence and complicity” during the Shoah informed his teaching and writing. He is the retired editor of Catholic New Times and is active as a community theologian in his parish and community.

Theology in the Vineyard attempts to find God in the stuff of life where politics, history,culture and economics meet. It has both a virtual and a human face. When it hits the road as it has in the Picton area in two Vineyards, Chadsey’s Cairns and The Grange, it brings like minded Christians together who do not accept the present patriarchal and clerical domination of the Roman Catholic Church. This was of course before the reactionary papacies of John Paul ll and Benedict XVl. These good church men carried the predictable reaction against the revolutionary Council which  was the greatest cahnge in catholic thining since the 16th century .As herman Pottmeyer, German theologian stated “The work of Vatican ll has remained an unfinished  building site. I t is a  transitional council.”

There is more  movement in store as the Holy Spirit never stops renovating. as Vatican ll insisted: The Church is  semper reformanda, always in the process of renewing itself .The necessary change is the decentalization and democratization of the church towards “the people of God” metaphor which the Council insisted on. We are an absolutely egalitarian people, a communio, a discipleship of equals .Baptism assures this. It not Holy Orders which  is the first sacrament.

The Church is an institution and all institutions react to insulate themselves against change.The brakes applied by the last two popes  have failed. As Pope Francis has stated Vatican ll can not be reversed. This present pope  gives believers hope.

When the Vineyard began Catholics were losing hope. It began as an invitation to all to make the Church a more inclusive meeting place and a more credible witness to God’s reign among people. The bishops had failed terribly to hear the Catholic people. The John Paul ll bishops famously listened to only one voice, Rome. This has been an egregious failure. The brilliant martyred German theologian Dietrich Bonhoeffer warned :

The first service that one owes to others in community consists in listening to them. Just as love for God begins with listening to His Word, so the beginning of love for the brethren is learning to listen to them. It is God’s love for us that He not only gives His Word but also lends us His ear … Many people are looking for an ear that will listen. They do not find it among Christians because these Christians are talking where they should be listening. But he who can no longer listen to his brother will soon be no longer listening to God either; he will be doing nothing but prattle in the presence of God. This is the beginning of the death of the spiritual life, and, in the end, there is nothing left but spiritual chatter and clerical condescension arrayed in pious words,”

The first Theology in the Vineyard (Sept.17, 2005) was inspired by the Vatican Council’s statement ( Lumen Gentium) which invited “lay people to express their opinions which concern the common good of the church.” These comments spoke volumes:

“I feel like a starving orphan …”

“I am exasperated by the institution …”

“There is a need for real change in Christianity. I need to step away from the institution to energize …”

“We can’t count on clergy in parishes. I came here to hear what people can do …”

“There is respect here for diverse opinions and a lack of fear …”

“I support a social justice church … how better to spend a Saturday …”

“I thirst for the days of Vatican II …”

“I am in dire need of spiritual nourishment.”

“We’re retreating into the past. There is real frustration and a need to renew. There’s something radically wrong when a pastor changes, everything changes. There’s something wrong. That power should not exist.

“I am disillusioned and in need of hope …”

“I have four kids and thirst for a relevant church …”

“I just love the dialogue …

“I feel frustrated, alone and unwanted and I have no intention of leaving …”

“I want to know where that great hope of Vatican II vanished …”

The dialogue continues. Stay tuned.

Advertisements

1 Comment »

  1. 1

    “I feel like a starving orphan …”

    TRY FEEDING ON THE EUCHARIST.

    “I am exasperated by the institution …”

    TRY TO GET PAST YOUR ADOLESCENT REBELLION, AND YOU’LL FEEL BETTER.

    “There is a need for real change in Christianity. I need to step away from the institution to energize …”

    A MARRIAGE BETWEEN TWO PEOPLE IS AN INSTITUTION. YOU CAN’T GET AWAY FROM INSTITUTIONS, EXCEPT PERHAPS BY LIVING AS A HERMIT IN THE WILDERNESS OF MONTANA. AS FOR ENERGIZING, TRY THE EUCHARIST.

    “We can’t count on clergy in parishes. I came here to hear what people can do …”

    NO, YOU CANNOT. YOU CANNOT COUNT ON ANYONE, BECAUSE EVERYONE IS SINFUL, AND THEY’LL LET YOU DOWN EVENTUALLY. BUT YOU CAN COUNT ON CHRIST, AND HE CALLS FUMBLING HUMAN BEINGS TO BE PRIESTS, NOT SO THAT WE CAN COUNT ON THEM, BUT SO THAT THEY CAN PROVIDE US WITH WHAT WE REALLY NEED, NAMELY THE EUCHARIST (CHRIST).

    INTERESTING THAT THIS KEEPS COMING BACK TO THE EUCHARIST.

    “There is respect here for diverse opinions and a lack of fear …”

    NO, THERE ISN’T. THERE’S NO RESPECT FOR CATHOLIC ORTHODOXY, OR POLITICAL CONSERVATISM.

    “I support a social justice church … how better to spend a Saturday …”

    CHRIST DIED FOR ALL OF US. THAT’S UNIVERSAL JUSTICE. UNLESS THE LORD BUILDS THE HOUSE, IN VAIN DO THE BUILDERS LABOR. ONLY WHEN IT IS NO LONGER YOU WHO LIVE, BUT CHRIST WHO LIVES IN YOU, WILL YOU BE A CHANNEL OF REAL JUSTICE. YOU BECOME CHRIST THROUGH THE EUCHARIST.

    “I thirst for the days of Vatican II …”

    THERE IS NO SUCH THING AS DAYS OF VATICAN II. START LIVING FOR TODAY.

    “I am in dire need of spiritual nourishment.”

    I KNOW. I SENSED THAT. TRY THE EUCHARIST.

    “We’re retreating into the past.

    NO, YOU ARE RETREATING INTO THE PAST. YOU JUST SAID: “I THIRST FOR THE DAYS OF VATICAN II”. IT’S AMAZING THAT WE ONLY SEE IN OTHERS WHAT WE SEE IN OURSELVES.

    There is real frustration and a need to renew.

    TRANSLATION: I AM FRUSTRATED, AND I NEED TO RENEW.

    AGAIN, TRY THE EUCHARIST.

    There’s something radically wrong when a pastor changes, everything changes. There’s something wrong. That power should not exist.

    THAT’S TRUE. BUT IF YOU WERE THE PASTOR, EVERYTHING WOULD CHANGE. THAT’S ALL YOU KEEP TALKING ABOUT, NAMELY, THE NEED TO CHANGE. THEY’RE JUST DOING WHAT YOU WOULD DO. THAT POWER SHOULD NOT EXIST, EXCEPT IN THE HANDS OF SOMEONE LIKE YOU.

    “I am disillusioned and in need of hope …”

    CHRIST IS OUR HOPE. HOPE IN HIM.

    “I have four kids and thirst for a relevant church …”

    THE CHURCH THAT CHRIST ESTABLISHED IS RELEVANT, BECAUSE CHRIST IS RELEVANT, AND THAT CHURCH HAS ONLY ONE THING TO GIVE YOU: CHRIST. NO IDEOLOGY, NO POLITICAL SOLUTIONS, JUST CHRIST. YOUR FRUSTRATION COMES FROM TRYING TO FIND CHRIST WHERE CHRIST CANNOT BE FOUND.

    “I just love the dialogue …

    WHICH IS WHY YOU NEVER DIALOGUE ON THIS FORUM.

    “I feel frustrated, alone and unwanted and I have no intention of leaving …”

    AS LONG AS YOU ARE STAYING, TRY CONCENTRATING ON THE MASS, THAT IS, THE EUCHARIST.

    “I want to know where that great hope of Vatican II vanished …”

    THE HOPE OF THE CHURCH IS ALWAYS THE SAME: CHRIST IS THE SAME YESTERDAY AND TODAY. NOTHING CHANGES. YOU PUT YOUR HOPE IN SOME UTOPIA. THAT WAS YOUR MISTAKE. BUT THERE IS STILL TIME TO CORRECT IT.

    The dialogue continues.Stay tuned.

    I’VE TUNED IN FOR A WHILE NOW, AND THERE’S NO DIALOGUE HERE. EITHER NO ONE IS LISTENING, OR YOU ARE A LIAR. WHICH IS IT?


RSS Feed for this entry

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: