Carol Goar and the Common Good


I do not know is star editoralist Carol Goar has an Order  of Canada

but she should have.

Nobody in this country has so vigorously defended the Common Good as

her.The woman has been idefatigable in her persistent defense of one

of the cardinal points of Catholic Social Teaching. While never using

religious language Goar  always forges strong moral arguments on behalf

of a true national interest. Without naming enemies of the common

good, she  always manages to skewer the apostles of greed, male and


Her latest column in today’s Star is a classic.Entitled Business looks in mirror and winces, Goar begins like this

Contrition would be too much to expect of the corporate executives and financial wizards who tipped the global economy into a recession last fall. But there is some serious rethinking going on, judging by this year’s convocation at the Rotman School at the University of Toronto.

Read the column for yourselves but if there ever was a constituency needing to be taken to the woodshed it is the busines class and the catstrophe it has created.

I think we are all a bit sick of those MBA grads coming out of business schools with inflated senses of entitlement and compensation way beyond their contribution to society.

Goar summarizes Professor Michael Porter of Harvard’s remarks to the Rotman Business school like this

He placed most of the blame on chief executives who became so obsessed with shareholder value in the 1990s that they lost sight of the real economy in which goods and services are produced, profits are earned and people make a living.

They judged their worth by the appeal of their stocks. Bankers and brokers cheered them on, treating companies that beat investors’ expectations (even if they did it by cutting corners) as superstars and companies that produced solid, steady returns as wallflowers.

In a lovely understatement Goar described the response:

The audience of 300 – composed of corporate executives and Rotman faculty and graduates – listened attentively and asked a few questions. The applause was more respectful than enthusiastic.

I’ll bet.


Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: